ARCHIVES

PHASE 4 Update
April 8, 2008

Chairman's Update

April 16, 2007

 
Update from Dutchess County on PHASE 4
Released April 8, 2008

Millerton north to Undermountain Road


Dear Rail Trail Enthusiast,
Phase IV of the Harlem Valley Rail Trail is being pursued by Dutchess County Government as aggressively as possible. We are currently in the preliminary design phase of Phase IV.

The major milestone we are working towards is the completion of a Final Design Report. The purpose of the Final Design Report is to develop and assess alternatives and their associated environmental impacts, and select a preferred alternative. The Design Report is used to satisfy requirements of the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) and the State Environmental Quality Review Act (SEQRA). The Design Report is also reviewed by NYSDOT as a necessary step within the federal aid process. Final design cannot begin until these environmental procedures are completed.

In our efforts to complete the Final Design Report, we are in the midst of several processes that involve other agencies.

The New York State Department of Environmental Conservation’s (NYSDEC) and the Army Corps of Engineers’ (COE) are currently reviewing the November 2007 jurisdictional wetlands submittal. The NYSDEC has conducted a walkthrough to do some field verification of wetland boundaries and informally has said that they see no significant delineation issues.
NYSDEC and COE will either agree with the wetland delineations or ask for boundary revisions. Once the wetland boundaries are confirmed, preliminary design can proceed, wetland impacts from construction can be quantified and the environmental assessment of alternatives can be completed.

One of the potential environmental constraints we are facing is the presence of Bog Turtles, an endangered species, whose habitat is adjacent to, and in some cases on, the abandoned railway bed. Trail alternatives will be assessed to determine necessary mitigation and possible additional study regarding Bog Turtle habitat.

The trail design report will also be reviewed by NYSDEC as an Article 24 Freshwater Wetlands Permit. NYSDEC has the regulatory ability to require mitigations such as building elevated portions of the trail (e.g. – boardwalk on stilts) in order to minimize physical disturbances to the wetlands and/or wetland buffers. NYSDEC may say portions of the wetlands, particularly the Class 1 wetlands, may not be disturbed at all. In that case, portions of the trail will need to be re-routed.

We are actively engaged in meeting all requirements to keep the process moving forward. The timeliness of regulatory agency reviews and the resultant “negotiated” wetland and endangered species mitigations may have significant impact on the project schedule, design and construction cost.

We are striving to design Phase IV of the HVRT so the wetlands are a scenic and valuable feature. The project mitigations for beaver activity, endangered species, wetlands and wetland buffers are challenging aspects of the work requiring additional time and effort. The public can be assured this time and effort will be worth it, as the final trail design of Phase IV will strike a balance between environmental responsibility and responsiveness to the needs of trail users.

Gregory V. Bentley, P. E.